Tssipa
07-14-2005, 12:23 PM
Does everyone agree with me when I say that, God created this world and everyone in it?
Would you also agree with me that God makes everything happen and he oversees onveryone and everything and that he is in complete control of all that takes place in the universe?
SO keeping that in mind, help me understand this concept. Why would something that God created be wrong? If it's not supposed to exist, then why did God create it? Why did he let it happen?
OceanofMemories
07-14-2005, 12:34 PM
well lets ask it in an example. G-d created the concept of stealing. does that mean that it is right to do it? i mean, how can it be wrong? He created it. :)
i had a class on this topic. ill try to find the notes and type up a good dvar Torah for u.
Jew4Life
07-14-2005, 12:35 PM
Why would something that God created be wrong? If it's not supposed to exist, then why did God create it? Why did he let it happen?
what exactly are you refering to???
Jewishguy
07-14-2005, 12:37 PM
hmmmmmmm i think this all started when The Snake approached Eve in the Garden Of Eden. Kogda luduam xorosho vsegda oni eto ne ponimaut oni xotyat chto to eshe lutshe. im vsegda chto to malo. Yea thats why some of us called Evil Creatures. Nam vsegda chto to malo. But it is impossible to question G-d. Last person who did was Moshe.........voobshe ya bi posovetoval Torah pochitat tam napisano mnogo umnogo na etu temu. G-d said if u dont follow his rules u will suffer (Israel). K primeru, on skazal Israely vignat' vsex drugix narodov. As u can see israel did not do it and now paying the price. Another example, gay parad in the Holy Land. Kakoi uzhaz. G-d told jews to destroy such people.......i could go on and on .........many examples.
In short it is not G-d who created evil it is us as people who created it and continue improvise .........
Executive
07-14-2005, 01:16 PM
Does everyone agree with me when I say that, God created this world and everyone in it?
Would you also agree with me that God makes everything happen and he oversees onveryone and everything and that he is in complete control of all that takes place in the universe?
SO keeping that in mind, help me understand this concept. Why would something that God created be wrong? If it's not supposed to exist, then why did God create it? Why did he let it happen?
What you consider to be "wrong" is very subjective. It is relative to your human, earth based point of view. In the realm of G-d, there is no "right and wrong". Everything is as it should be....
OlorinGandalf
07-14-2005, 01:27 PM
Does everyone agree with me when I say that, God created this world and everyone in it?
Would you also agree with me that God makes everything happen and he oversees onveryone and everything and that he is in complete control of all that takes place in the universe?
SO keeping that in mind, help me understand this concept. Why would something that God created be wrong? If it's not supposed to exist, then why did God create it? Why did he let it happen?
Statement number 1 - agree
Statement number 2 - do not agree
This world is not ruled by g-d. He gave us all a gift - freedom of choice. Once we ate of that infamous tree of good an evil, we realised of the existance of that "freedom." Once we did eat that fruit, we were in control of our actions - both right and wrong actions. He gave us a guide book to tell appart those two and which way to follow. The thing that remained with g-d is the final word, final judgement.
Tssipa
07-14-2005, 03:29 PM
What you consider to be "wrong" is very subjective. It is relative to your human, earth based point of view. In the realm of G-d, there is no "right and wrong". Everything is as it should be....
exactly how i feel. Yes i agree with this, and that is why I have those questions.
BuharskayaDeva
07-17-2005, 09:59 AM
Unfotunately we don't have the power to understand G-d's nature as far as why did He create the good and the evil...our purpose in life is to accept both concepts and hopefully choose the right path in life with our freedom of choice.